Skip To Main Content

The Chill of Choosing Thrill over Caution on a Snowy Winter’s Day

  • Upper School
The Chill of Choosing Thrill over Caution on a Snowy Winter’s Day
Devon O'Neil speaking to upper school students during chapel

It was 2019 and outdoors writer Devon O’Neil was attending an Infamous Stringdusters concert at the Ten Mile Music Hall in Frisco, Colorado. As he chatted with a friend he learned about a tragedy two years earlier just outside the hamlet of Salida, CO, that had ripped the town of 5,000 apart emotionally.

In early January 2017, Brett Beasley, his daughter Brooke, and a couple of other fathers and their teenage children had embarked on a short backcountry ski vacation in the mountains 70 miles north of Salida. It was to be a bonding experience for the families. And it was expected to be incredibly safe for such an excursion.

Yet on the first morning of skiing, Brett and 15-year-old Cole Walters-Schaler set out from Uncle Bud’s ski hut on what they expected to be a 20-minute lap. They planned to be back before the others were ready to attack the fresh powder that had begun to fall.
 
Unfortunately, Cole and Brett became trapped in an unexpected blizzard, cut off from the others for 30 hours, overcome by hypothermia and disoriented by the blizzard and the elements. Before they could be rescued, Brett died on his forty-seventh birthday. Cole recovered, but the emotional scars left him unable to discuss the experience for years.
 
Immediately drawn to this story, O’Neil set out to write about it, initially viewing it as a lengthy magazine article. But the emotional trauma and wounds throughout the town of Salida were too raw and fresh and painful to share with a reporter. It would be six years before O’Neil could bring the story to the public, and not in a magazine piece but an excellent book, The Way Out.
 
On Monday, October 26, O’Neil came to McCallie to speak to the Upper School about the lessons that should be learned from that tragedy, about the inherent dangers in nature, about the risk and reward of the wilderness, about the seemingly insignificant choices we sometimes make that can become life-changing, or, far worse, life-ending events.
 
A single passage in the book, uttered by a friend to Brett two months before the ski trip, foreshadowed his death. The friend told of a hiking accident involving his brother-in-law that had led to the brother-in-law’s death. Said the friend to Brett: “That’s how important each decision is. Every step you take in nature, even tiny ones, can totally change everything. And you never know when.”
 
You could argue those words should be on a billboard or a poster at the entrance to every outdoor activity. They certainly should have been followed more closely by Beasley, who went off with Cole that morning without a cell phone, heavy clothing, a compass or map, or matches with which they could have started a fire in an attempt to stay somewhat warm in the snowstorm.
 
Or as O’Neil observed during his Chapel address, “Sometimes the mountains give and sometimes they take.”
 
But to listen closely to O’Neil inside the Chapel, and in later discussions with students, was to realize his appearance wasn’t only about the book. It was also about recognizing a good story, and fleshing it out, and being patient when roadblocks temporarily halt your path and your goal.
 
As he said of talking to his friend at the Infamous Stringdusters concert, “The story found me at that concert, but it took me six years to write it.”
 
O’Neil’s coming to McCallie to speak is its own example of unexpected outcomes, though in a good way. History Department chair Duke Richey '86 has been working on a book about the rise of Aspen, Colorado, from a mining town prior to World War II to perhaps the nation’s most famous ski destination over the past 60 years. Doing research for the book, he stumbled across a picture from an Aspen watering hole that included WWII veteran Robert “Snuffy” O’Neil, a member of the 10th Mountain Division, which had trained in Colorado, and many of the soldiers moved there after the war. Through further research, he tracked down Devon O’Neil, to present him with the photo and learn a little bit about his grandfather, who briefly settled in Aspen after WWII to earn a living as both a cartoonist and a ski instructor before moving back to the East Coast.
 
(A small-world story: Devon O’Neil encountered a handful of men his grandfather’s age, Snuffy died before he was born, at a ski lift one day. They had 10th Division stickers on their skis. He asked if any of them knew his granddad. They all did and had stories to share. It turned out one of the men, Andre Benoit, was the father of the great American distance runner Joan Benoit Samuelson, who won two Boston Marathons and the 1984 Olympic gold medal in Los Angeles in the women’s marathon.)
 
A month or so before Richey met up with O’Neil in Colorado, McCallie’s Dean of Curriculum, Sumner McCallie, had put The Way Out on the school’s annual summer reading list. As Richey visited with O’Neil in Aspen, the two hit it off and Richey asked if he’d like to come speak to McCallie’s students. The rest, as they say, is history, O’Neil not only speaking in Chapel but also taking a couple of days to chat with Upper School students over lunch and in classrooms.
 
Devon O'Neil speaking with McCallie students in a classroom
 
“I was so impressed by the inquisitiveness of the students,” said O’Neil of the student body. “They have a much broader, mature view of life than you would expect to see from 16-17 year olds growing up in Tennessee. Many of the questions were deeper and more thoughtful than I expected. I didn’t know anything about McCallie before I came, but it’s a very impressive school, very impressive students.”
 
Writing the book, interviewing more than 100 people, slowly earning the trust of Salida’s residents, whom O’Neil labeled “very private people,” changed his own perspective of his life. Before the book, O’Neil sought out thrills in all sorts of outdoor activities, ignoring possible risks to experience the high of climbing a mountain or skiing down a steep slope.
 
“I thought I needed that thrill,” he said. “But after writing the book, after seeing what that mindset can do, I realized I didn’t need the thrill, I only wanted the thrill. What I needed was my family, my wife and my two kids.”
 
If only Brett Beasley had realized that before it was too late.
 
Devon O'Neil author of The Way Out

 


  • chapel